[Full-Disclosure] Response to comments on Security and Obscurity

[yaakov yehudi]

A firewall is more akin to a specialized filter medium, but filter mediums aren't used as the entrance or exit to a military base.  

It is probably possible to find analogies between the information security world and physical - but only on a piecemeal basis, and that is simply irrelevant and pointless.

Peter might be much better to concentrate on the realities and forget about straw-man analogies.  What do you think?

---------------------------------------
Barry Fitzgerald wrote... 

Well, you can try to make an analogy between this and a well-secured network.  The problem is that the analogies don't align.  A firewall isn't really like a gate with an armed guard at it.  

---------------------------------------


Ya'akov Yehudi
Information Security Officer
Project Tehila
Ministry of Finance
Israel
http://www.tehila.gov.il/Tehila1/english_site